August 24, 2009

I hate Sinatra... except when sung by this other guy...

It seems like all the local Starbucks have begun playing old swing era crooners like Frank Sinatra, Perry Como and Tony Bennett. I'm not a Sinatra fan, especially when I've heard "New York New York" numerous times, with each Americano, over the past two weeks.

But there's one exception: I loved hearing Sinatra when he was sung by this other guy...

Here's the story:

My wife Grace and I were sitting in our local 'bucks, crowded on a Sunday, with chattering patrons, and the same Frank playing on the speakers, yet again.

As Frank started unrolling into the second verse of "New York New York", I started hearing voices behind me. Above them, one weak voice, getting louder, singing along "Top of the Heap! A-Number-One! King of the Hill!", getting louder, and the people behind us chanting along, going "Yeah buddy! Right on!" It was a mentally challenged man, out with his housemates and his care workers, standing up with his arms outstretched, singing for all he was worth in his happy little voice, as if he was belting the chorus out right in the middle of Times Square. "Newwwwww Yoooorrrk!"

As the song ended we were all smiles, and Grace and I, and all the singer's pals and their care workers gave him a nice little round of applause. It was a sweet moment, watching someone else's unbridled joy at the act of singing...

To me, much better than anything I ever heard from Frank Sinatra...

2 comments:

Fish & Bicycles said...

John, don't you think "hate" is an overly strong word? I mean, this is the Blog of Love! ;-)

Seriously, have you listened to Sinatra's earlier music? "New York, New York" is a novelty song and, as you know, has been played to death, so even if it was a good song burnout tends to overshadow.

I love his Capitol Records recordings from the 50s and 60s, and his Live in Paris album is a wonderfully intimate set, recorded with a sextet.

Say, I'll be interested to see if you can figure out who I am. I've started a new blog, have linked to Blog of Love, so stop by when you have a chance.

Seeya!

E. John Love said...

He he... I did a little thinkin' and a little surfin', so I know who this is now... Fair enough about New York being a novelty tune... I guess I'm willing to give ol' Blue Eyes an even break, musically... :)